Attention all NFL executives and coaches: If your offseason training activities are voluntary, stop complaining when a player doesn't volunteer to forfeit his vacation time.
ESPN ran with a story on its website today saying that some Washington Redskins players are unhappy that defensive tackle Albert Haynesworth hasn't reported to voluntary camps.
I actually understand the problem the 'Skins have with Haynesworth staying home. They're busting their butts and they want the superstar lineman to be out there doing it with them. After all, as defensive end Phillip Daniels said, "There is no room for negotiation at 4-12."
That was Washington's record last year when the defense played out of a base 4-3 package. New defense coordinator Jim Haslett apparently plans to install a 3-4 scheme, which Haynesworth has no desire to play in.
Fine. Criticize the overpriced lineman for not wanting to play in a defense because he likes another one better. Criticize him for the apparent attitude problems he flashed all through a disappointing first season with the Redskins.
But don't criticize Haynesworth purely for not attending a voluntary mini camp.
It's one of the more absurd aspects of the NFL. Every team holds voluntary mini camps and conducts voluntary conditioning programs. As their name implies, these camps and programs are not required. Coaches cannot force players to attend or participate. Players cannot be fined or otherwise disciplined within the team for failing to volunteer.
And yet, every offseason, a coach will call out one of his players in the media for not attending a voluntary camp. He'll say he really needs the guy there, and that he's disappointed he didn't show up.
Coach may not be able to fine or bench his player. But he can certainly apply pressure and wreck a player's reputation by tricking the public into thinking he has done something wrong.
Again, the camps are voluntary. We ain't even talkin' 'bout practice. We're talkin' about practice that is not required!
How many of you 9-to-5ers volunteer to come into work on Saturdays? Sure, your boss might like it. But if he doesn't make you, you're not doing it. What's interesting about this particular case is that the players are the ones calling out Haynesworth. But they're not any more right to do so than the coach.
Players in the NFL live a good life. They make lots and lots and lots of money playing a game that most of us loved to play for free as kids. But they pay the price, too, with devastating injuries, the lifelong effects of which we are only just now beginning to comprehend.
So even if I'd love for every player on every team to show up for practice, required or not, and work with their teammates to get better every chance they get, it doesn't make a player wrong to decide to sit out of those voluntary work outs.
I don't know Albert Haynesworth. Maybe he's a terrible teammate and a general pain in the ass. But if a nine year NFL veteran with two Pro Bowls under his belt and an enormous, unhealthy, but required lineman gut above that belt wants to sit a few out in May, I don't see the problem.